9 Best Peanut Butter Dog Treats

Updated Jul 28, 2026

Peanut butter dog treats means PB leads the flavor story—crunchy boxes, soft jars, and twist sticks. Our peanut-butter-banana and pumpkin-peanut-butter guides own those combo recipes; this list still includes one PB-banana soft pick when PB is co-primary. Pick a PB format.

Our top picks

Swipe →
Find your dog’s best match 3 questions Answer three quick questions and we’ll point you to the best pick for your dog.

Our picks, explained

How we made this list

We required peanut butter as a lead flavor and compared crunchy restocks, soft chews, and rawhide-free twists without duplicating combo-flavor specialty guides.

  1. PB-first shopping. Banana-forward and pumpkin-PB combo guides stay separate—check blurbs when a SKU shares DNA with those pages.
  2. Useful format spread. Training, everyday, and special-reward lanes stay distinct.
  3. Portion-aware choices. Treats complement a complete diet; they do not replace meals.
  4. Label-first decisions. We favor an intelligible ingredient and format story over vague wellness promises.
  5. Real-world handling. Tearability, crunch, chew time, and bag size matter as much as the headline flavor.

FAQ

Crunchy or soft peanut butter?

Crunchy 5 lb boxes restock; soft jars suit seniors and rapid training.

Are Pill Pockets peanut butter treats?

They are peanut-flavored pockets—utility format for pill hiding, still PB-led flavor.

DreamBone twists here?

Included as rawhide-free PB chew sticks—supervise like any stick chew.

Same as Old Mother Hubbard P-Nuttier?

Two P-Nuttier SKUs cover classic vs larger bag—both PB biscuit trainers.

This is general pet guidance, not veterinary advice. Check with your veterinarian before introducing new treats — especially for puppies, dogs with allergies, or any medical diet.

Affiliate disclosure: we may earn a commission from Amazon links. Prices and availability change.